THE PHINISI : INDONESIA BEST YATCH EVER
What have we done to change these craft for a newly defined purpose as a yacht or charter vessel…?
Our goal has been to preserve the extraordinary aesthetic tradition
of these vessels and to carry their best qualities forward, but to
improve them where needed in order to serve their new purpose as charter
yachts.
Changes: Our aim has been to provide greater strength and longevity
of structure than is found among local craft. Our goals in so doing
have been to reduce maintenance, to provide a high degree of comfort,
improve the performance under power, and to increase the long term
safety of the ship.
In order to create a luxury yacht or
charter vessel out of the traditionally built Phinisi or KLM types has
mainly been a matter of sizing and arranging the cabins for their new
purpose and to refine the hull shape for use as a yacht, rather than as a
much more burdensome cargo vessel.
As a bonus, the more refined yacht hull shape is much more
comfortable in the sea than the much more boxy cargo hull types, which
have a reputation for having a rather harsh and unkind motion when not
deeply laden with cargo. After all, a yacht need only carry a load of
fuel, food, passengers, and their water toys.
Power: Motive power is provided by a relatively much larger diesel
engine than would be locally used. This is for vastly improved
performance, safety and convenience as well as in order to achieve a
more dependable charter schedule. For example, where we would specify
an engine of around 850 hp, an equivalently sized local cargo vessel
would rarely have more than around 250hp to 350 hp…!
Of course the engines we specify would
be larger still if it were required to get these boats to reach their
full theoretical hull speed (i.e. an S/L of around 1.34). However above
a speed to length ratio of around 1.10 the power requirements and the
consequent fuel use, as well as the machinery cost become excessive.
Tradition: Still further requirements have been to blend the
excellent Konjo / Bugis boat building traditions with a few of the
specific requirements of the West, primarily in terms of comfort,
structure, safety, and stability.
Structure: A number of structural improvements over the typical
cargo vessel construction have been specified. These were not dramatic
changes in terms of the construction methods, but definitely they were a
big change in terms of finesse and quality, so cumulatively the changes
have been very important to the structure.
Examples of our modifications to the structure are that we have specified:
* The use of only top quality timbers;
* That the timbers be of the maximum obtainable length;
* That the proximity of joints in planking and other structure be according to Germanischer Lloyd’s requirements;
* That the frames be top quality and nicely finished;
* That proper scarf joints be used for all structural members;
* That an increased quantity and higher quality of fastenings be used throughout;
* That there be substantial bilge and deck stringers inside;
* That there be watertight bulkheads as specified by GL;
* That there be heavy duty long length engine girder timbers in order to
handle the additional stresses imposed by the higher powered machinery.
These changes plus many less obvious
refinements to the methods used for joining the primary structural
members have all gone into the specification for a robust and long
lasting wooden ship.
Cumulatively, these changes have been very significant – and indeed
there is quite a large difference in terms of the quality and integrity
of the resulting vessel as compared to the vessels built for cargo.
Even more dramatically, these refinements offer a vast improvement over
the more typical poorly planned attempt to turn one of these local craft
into a private yacht or charter vessel.
CAN A NEW WOODEN YACHT BE BUILT ECONOMICALLY…?
Yes! …and of course that is the ultimate goal…!
Given that such a vessel is largely based on the very common local
Phinisi / KLM types, it can still be very economically built in
Indonesia using locally available timbers and locally available talent.
Unfortunately, we have consistently
observed that due to the relatively low cost of building the wooden
structure of these vessels, there always will be a steady supply of
misguided Westerners who approach the Indonesian boat builders with the
idea of turning one of their locally built craft into a yacht or charter
boat at the lowest possible cost. Most often the result is extremely
poor – mainly due to extremely inadequate planning and virtually
non-existent project management.
These half hearted attempts to create a
yacht inevitably result in an ill-conceived and / or poorly executed
vessel, i.e. one that has not been ‘designed’ nor built to any standard,
nor even effectively ‘managed’ during construction. Although the local
builders are very capable of producing excellent results with their own
local vessel types, having been developed for carrying cargo they are
not ordinarily so well suited to being turned into yachts.
Even worse, when these indigenous
vessels get arbitrarily modified by various misguided ‘owner requests’
during construction, the final product can be shockingly bad – even to
the point of being unsafe. Of course there are exceptions, but they are
not so common.
Most of the pre-existing charter vessels or private yachts that we
have seen for sale in Indonesia are really not worth much. Yes there
are exceptions, however it should be kept in mind that any cargo vessels
built for knowledgeable local cargo skippers that are still in
excellent shape… it is extremely unlikely to actually find one for sale
while there is still some working life remaining.
The overall point is that whether new or old, there is a very big
difference between those vessels and the likes of what I have outlined
in these pages.
The essential differences…?
* The amount of planning;
* The verification of structure per GL standards;
* The assurance of stability per IMO standards;
* Designing a shape that will behave well as a yacht;
* And finally, following through to assure that the vessel is constructed accordingly via an on-site team.
Having taken these steps, you can be assured that the resulting vessel will be a fine, safe, robust, and long lasting asset.
THE PURSUIT OF QUALITY
Building an Indonesian wooden vessel is a unique sort of adventure. It
is not unusual for someone to surf the web, see the Indonesian designs
we have created, note their excellent qualities, print a few images off
the web show the builders and ask them “can you build one like this?”
This has occurred several times. Those events have been verified and
duly noted.
The next crazy step is for someone to order ‘Study Plans’ and attempt
to do the same. I’d venture to say that the result will possibly be
better than if they had made a drawing in the sand (as is also very
common), but nowhere near the calibre of vessel that could have been.
Due to this apparently common tendency
amongst those who are wild enough to want to build a boat in Indonesia,
we have priced our ‘Estimating Plans’ for these vessels so that there is
relatively little reason not to go for the whole package of ‘Building
Plans’ which actually includes the vessel’s hull shape..! In other
words, if you already know that a given design is what you want there is
little point in ordering the Estimating Plans separately, which only
runs the cost up (and causes us extra work..!). Please review our
complete Plans List for more information.
Overall, I want the as-built result with these craft to be the best
that it possibly can be. If owners go off into the bush with a half
baked plan, they certainly will not end up with a fully baked result.
Since our aim is to encourage only the very best, we wish to arm our
clients with all the information that will require.
CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISION
It is our intent to remain on-call as needed during construction to help
supervise the information flow to the builders and to answer
questions. We do not get involved in actual project management per se,
and we do not get physically involved in the build itself, except purely
in an advisory capacity.
However via our prior various projects in Indonesia we have become
familiar with a number of excellent contacts on Java and Sulawesi and we
have a mountain of highly useful information to accompany our plans,
including a clearly laid out strategy to achieve the build and how to
put a team in place to get the best result.
We also have a short list of those who should be avoided…!
HOW TO DO IT RIGHT
Planning: We find that the key to success with any project of this
magnitude is thorough planning, done well in advance of any actual boat
building being done, and in advance of any contract arrangements being
made.
We therefore view the design of the vessel as being the first
essential ingredient to success. The other essential components are
that highly skilled builders be found, and that during the building of
the boat there be adequate communication via competent on-site project
management.
Our contribution with these craft is not just to design an interior
and general layout suited to the owner’s chartering or yachting
requirements, but also to specify a pre-determined hull shape; to
specify the structure so that only the highest quality wood and hot dip
galvanized fastenings be used; and then to follow through during
construction in order to assure that the requested enhancements to the
structure be made and the original plans be followed faithfully.
The following is a brief outline of the process we have found to work best….
Building: For maximum economy, the ideal build venue for a wooden
hull of this size (meaning all the heavy woodwork of the hull, deck, and
superstructure) will always be close to the best supply of good
timbers. Presently in Indonesia this means Kalimantan (the Indonesian
part of the island of Borneo).
The Shape: With each of our boat projects in Indonesia, in order to
achieve the intended hull form we have made use of temporary internal
mould frames. The hull shape is first “lofted” and then the mould
frames are built to match the lofting. The mould frames are then
erected onto the keel to act as a guide for the planking. This allows us
to pre-determine the section shapes in order to match our computer
generated hull shape (see image links above). You can observe the
process of creating mould frames at our Indonesian Boatbuilding Pictures
web page.
Per typical Indonesian practice, the planks are placed first, and the
frames afterward. This lends itself perfectly to the use of mould
frames to guide the shape. In other words, once the hull is planked
according to the moulded shape, the internal framing is added later,
very much as is the usual wooden boat building practice throughout
Asia. By this means we will have strayed from traditional methods only
slightly in order to achieve the required shape, and then as needed in
order to assure integrity of structure, longevity, and lessened
maintenance.
Outfitting: Once the
hull has been built, there is still plenty of additional work in
outfitting such a craft. To finish out the interior joinery, we have
found that the Konjo builders themselves are highly skilled and can
produce extremely fine results when guided by a clearly articulated
plan.
After that, the primary task is to properly specify and install the
mechanical and electrical equipment and various related systems.
The installation of the equipment and systems will always present a
challenge throughout Indonesia – mainly because the typical locally
built craft are extremely simply outfitted, therefore the requisite
engineering skills for a charter vessel or a yacht can be difficult to
find. Thus it is only in large harbors such as Jakarta or Surabaya or
Benoa in Bali where one will find the expertise required for the more
elaborate systems that are found on a yacht of this size.
Other locations are also available with regard to the installation of
systems… For example, Indonesia’s Batam island (near Singapore) has
become a possible venue for this stage of the work, and has the
advantage of little or no import duty and ready access to parts and
equipment in Singapore. Other possibly more enjoyable venues for
systems completion are Bali in Indonesia, Langkawi or Penang in
Malaysia, and Phuket in Thailand. Though labor costs will be higher in
Phuket than in Indonesia or Malaysia, labor will still be relatively
inexpensive when compared to any Western venue.
In Use: When finished according to the plans and specifications, the
result will be a world class yacht. Whether used as a private yacht or
in charter mode, this kind of vessel will offer a generous measure of
luxury to anyone who steps onboard.
Source :
http://www.kastenmarine.com/phinisi_quality.htm
For Plans : Please contact Mr. Michael Kasten at his email : michael@kastenmarine.com
